On a Tuesday, my cousin contacted me. Her voice was flat, weary in that manner which is the result of too many nights of reading law documents. I received a change of custody of the child notice, she said. I never imagined he could do that.
She had two weeks to respond.
That phone call altered my thought process with regard to custody law. Because she is not unusual. Most of the thousands of parents who have, annually, been blindsided by custody change documentation they do not comprehend, are caught by deadlines they were not prepared to think about. And the stakes were not less than that: time to spend with their children.
This is the guide to individuals who are just like her.
What Is a Notice of Child Custody Change?
A notice of child change of custody is a legal document that notifies a parent or a guardian or even the court that a party wishes to amend an already existing child custody order. It can alter who the child is living with, who is making decisions in the place of the child and also both.
Custody orders are not permanent. Life changes. Jobs move. Parents remarry. Children become adults and possess their requirements. The courts would require such orders to be revised in case the actual circumstances vary. The initial step in such process is a notice of child custody change.
This may apply to two types of custody:
Physical custody: involves having a sleeping place and the child spending most of his time.
Legal custody: The big decisions, such as the medical care, the school choice, and the religion, are made by the legal custodian.
One or both can be requested to be changed by a notice.
Why Would Someone File for a Custody Change?
This is what the parents tend to fall behind on. They believe that any excuse is good. It is not.
Courts do not vary custody orders simply because one of the parents desires more time or is dissatisfied with the existing arrangement. The circumstances must be changed materially. That phrase is key.
Common reasons courts accept include:
- A parent is relocating to another city or state
- A parent has developed a substance abuse problem
- A child’s needs have changed significantly (medical, educational, emotional)
- Domestic violence or abuse has occurred
- One parent is consistently blocking visitation
- A parent has remarried or had major changes in their living situation
- The child is older and has expressed a strong preference
This is the only question the courts always ask: what is in the best interest of the child? That is not a slogan. It is the legal norm that is practically used by judges.
The Emotional Reality Nobody Talks About
Herein lies what the legal guides omit.
Most parents do not get confused as the first thing when they receive the notice of child custody change. It is fear. Unsurpassed, entirely bodily fear that somebody is attempting to steal your child.
And that intimidation causes individuals to engage in acts that are counter-productive to their cause.
They fire off angry texts. They inform the children about what is going on. Their reason is that they are no longer following the current order as they assume it is changing. They make calls to the new partner of the other parent. They post about it online.
All those acts may find themselves in front of a judge.
Once, a family lawyer shared with me a piece of advice I have not forgotten: that the parent who remains calm and continues to show up to visit the child nearly always does better in court than the parent who loses their temper, even when the legal case the reactive parent is presenting is the better one.
Remaining calm does not mean being inactive. It is a strategy.
What Happens After the Notice Is Filed?
The process varies by state, but the general path looks like this:
Step 1: Filing. One parent (the “moving party”) files a petition to modify custody with the court. They include their reasons and what they want changed.
Step 2: Service. The other parent is officially “served” with the notice. This can happen via certified mail, a process server, or sometimes directly through the court.
Step 3: Response window. The served parent has a set number of days to respond, usually between 20 and 30 days depending on the state. Missing this window can result in a default judgment.
Step 4: Mediation (often required). Many courts require parents to try mediation before a judge gets involved. A neutral third party helps both sides reach an agreement without a trial.
Step 5: Hearing or trial. If mediation fails, a judge hears both sides. This can involve testimony, documents, and sometimes a guardian ad litem, which is a lawyer appointed to represent the child’s interests specifically.
Step 6: New order. The judge issues a modified custody order that replaces the old one.
The whole process can take anywhere from a few months to over a year, depending on the complexity and how backed up the court is.
Your Response Is More Important Than You Think
In case you get a child custody change notice, your response form is not an empty ritual. This is your first opportunity to explain yourself to the court.
A poor or ambiguous reaction gives the other parent an upper hand.
Your response should:
- Clearly state whether you agree or disagree with the proposed changes
- Explain why the other parent’s claimed “change in circumstances” is not valid, if that applies
- Show your involvement in the child’s life with specifics (school pickups, doctor visits, activities)
- Include any concerns you have about the other parent’s fitness or stability
In case you cannot afford an attorney, several counties possess legal assistance in family law. In other schools of law, there are free clinics. Bar associations also tend to have a lawyer referral with lower-priced first consults.
No reply without consulting with an attorney of family law at least one hour. Nothing is that much compared to the cost of the hour you risk in filing the wrong paperwork.
Relocating With a Child: The Most Common Trigger
And in case you are the parent who filled-out the notice, and your motivational reason is that you are moving, you must know something important.
The relocations are not just accepted by the courts, even in the case of a great job or an occasion of coming close to the family. The other parent also has rights, and they do not vanish simply because you want to move to some other city.
Most states require the relocating parent to:
- Give written notice to the other parent, often 30 to 90 days in advance
- File with the court if the other parent objects
- Show that the move is in the child’s best interest, not just the parent’s
The best interest test of relocation tends to consider factors such as the justification behind relocation, the resultant effect on the relationship of the child with the other parent, and what type of new custody would allow regular contact to still occur.
It is advisable to hire a lawyer to discuss the lease with you before you sign before relocating and sharing custody.
What If You Filed and Now Regret It?
This occurs more than individuals confess it.
Custody change filings occur in moments of anger or even of fear-based reasons, or when a parent has a new relationship and thinks he or she is ready to play a bigger role. Then there is the reality that the court is costly. It is slow. It places a child at the center. And in some cases, the parent finds out that the situation existing was working.
A custody modification petition can be withdrawn. This will be allowed in most states without punishment, provided the other party consents and the court has not made any orders yet.
You may also dismiss even without the consent of the other parent, but you need legal advice. Repeated filings may be viewed with skepticism by the courts, and frequent filing and withdrawal of filings may work against you when it comes to subsequent proceedings.
The Child’s Perspective
In any custody case, there is one party that did not volunteer to be there. And courts are giving that party more attention than they did.
In the vast majority of states, children of a specific age (usually 12 to 14, but again, it depends) can have a choice regarding their residence. There are states, which permit even younger children to be heard in case the judge finds it appropriate.
However, this is what the literature on child development informs us about it: children adapt more to change of custody when the adults surrounding them remain cooperative and do not use the process as a weapon.
Children are nearly aware of what is taking place than parents believe. They hear phone calls. They are exposed to texts placed on the counter. They experience stress at interactions. One of the parents cries upon drop-off.
The most supportive parents in the event of change is who discuss change with their children without being faulty, as much as possible keep the routines, and avoid discussing the legal aspects to their children.
That is not easy. But it is better than any legal strategy.
A Note on Parental Alienation Claims
Parental alienation refers to a situation where one parent makes every effort to sever the relationship between the child and the other. Courts take it seriously.
It is, however, inappropriate to mention that it is one of the most abused concepts of family law.
Be specific and be honest should you intend to raise alienation as a reason to make changes to custody. Alienation claims that are vague have been deployed as a tactical tool in courts. Unless there is actual evidence of the same, judges are not impressed by them: blocked communication, bad-mouthing in the presence of the child, visitation missed, a child who suddenly refuses to get in touch without a clear explanation.
In case alienation is taking place with you, record all this. Note down dates, times and what occurred. Screen grab messages. Record the instances of refusal of the visit or the child appearing coached. It is that paperwork that transforms an emotion into a courtroom case.
Before You Do Anything Else
If you received a notice today, do these three things before anything else:
1. Read the documents carefully. Note the deadlines. Court deadlines are not flexible.
2. Call a family law attorney. Even one consultation can change how you respond.
3. Keep the child’s life as normal as possible. School, sports, bedtime. Stability is both good parenting and a good strategy.
The court is not the enemy. The process is not the enemy. Each side of a properly functioning family court is aimed at identifying the best options that will benefit the child. Always have that at the core of all you do, and you will make better decisions along the way.
This article is general information and does not qualify as legal advice. State law differs substantially as regards custody. Seek the advice of a licensed attorney in family law in your jurisdiction.
Connect with me on LinkedIn for legal drafting, legal research and other legal matters!
